Originally posted by Sid Fishious:
Lyle, It's bizarre to hear you say that fishing 20-40ft. for blackmouth. I say bizarre because common practice says to fish right off the bottom.
Don't get me started!
The idea that blackmouth are found at or near the bottom, typically in 120-200' of water, is probably the THE single biggest and most universally accepted fallacy in all of salmondom.
Yes, it's true they can often be caught there, but this is only one of many places that BM will be found. In fact, if I don't hit fish at that depth fairly quickly, I won't waste much more of my time there. Maybe trolling back and forth all day long at that depth just reminds me too much of roadhunting the back roads for deer or elk. I mean sometimes you just have to park it and go where the game lives.
Giving up this stubbornly held misconception has without a doubt helped me to become a more successful BM fisherman. So much so, I am embarrassed to admit how long I bought into that crock.
Many years ago a well known "guide", who hates to troll, took me to a place where we could cast from the bank or drop a cartopper in to fish for BM casting pencil lead and bait in shallow water (30-60') with phenomenal results. Over the years, I have found quite a number of these places around the Sound with similar results. In fact I can easily say that my biggest BM have consistently come from depths of less than 60', some even at midday. This year has been no exception either.

If this tells you anything; the 120' shelf was my last stop when I fished derbys (it's been awhile).
My point is only that saying BM are only on the bottom, like some preach ad nauseam, is like saying that bass are only in the lilypads. One good thing about both bass and BM though is they are both usually pretty aggressive. If you're not hitting fish, it's probably because they're not there. So why not forget about switching lures or bait and try switching locations instead. You might be pleasantly surprised.
