i haven't used slinkies on a fly rod, and i doubt i ever will. all you need is a shot or two to get down.

i prefer swinging, but there's a lot of water that isn't great swing water, especially small creeks. it can be a fun way to fish, and a nice change of pace from swinging (it is a less relaxing way of fishing though).

i wouldn't give up on the swing, but if you find some water that looks fishy, but is gonna be impossible to swing through... break out the glo-bug and indicator and have some fun.

on this note, if nymphing... please take note of others on the river. being a hole hog is not very nice, whether nymphing or swinging.

above all else, if you are having fun and obeying the law... who cares.

chris