Isn't fishing for chums at the Hatchery Zone the same thing as fishing for chums in the Green River at Flaming Geyser (on redds) or fishing for silvers in the Green at the car body hole (on redds)?

The fish are in the exact same condition.

In all three instances the fish are there to blow their wads and die and there are plenty fisherman ready to take them home. Sounds like the same thing to me. I don't think it is a question of ethics as much as a question of how pre-smoked you like your fish to be when you take it home.
_________________________
Carl C.