You've seen my biggest Blacktail in the Oshawnassy thread. That is the biggest deer I have ever seen on the hoof, alive or dead. It was a horse. Sounds hard to believe, but it took two of us to drag this deer, any distance, on the ground. Call me a liar because we never had it weighed, but I would guess 230 to 240 on the hoof, and 200, gutted and skinned on the hook.