Obviously it depends where you fish and how...

You may notice that almost all the guides on the OP use aluminum boats. It's more a question of durability than one of rowability.

Why do you need to row upstream so much?

Perhaps that 50lbs is enough to add a stroke or two to your above mentioned scenario, and if that's the most relevant factor in your decision, then stick with glass...


Personally, i feel that my Willie 16X54 rowed like a champ. If I did miss a stroke or two, I'd much rather hit stuff in a metal boat...


I suggest trying to hitch a ride (or hire a guide) in a Willie and beg to row it for a while. I sold mine or I would offer up a ride.

(I also believe that the rowablity has a lot to do with the oars too: having the right weight and length will make it feel much easier. If possible, compare glass to metal with THE SAME OARS. )