Little confused here. Was the deer shot while in your back forty? If not then not much can be done. You have to live with the deer and neighbors. Trust me I have had more than my fare share of @ssh@ts for neighbors too. If he would have used a crossbow or just been less of an idiot this whole thing might have been avoided. #1 never approach a man armed with a gun and pester him about him breaking the law. Let the 50's take care of it. Where you greater than 500' off a public road? Does not matter if you are dead. More time to process scenario could have saved you a headache or atleast lessen your chances of an armed altercation. Oops failed to ask. Is he a first nationer fellow? They like their hunting easy. Say 12pm at oak creek during feeding time.