My uneducated responce is that you would both have the exact same odds on choice 1 he just has a chance to draw another choice and you don't because you didn't select one. My question is the AHE hunt unit Quinalt Ridge. What is it like? As a bowhunter you can hunt the mathaney unit which is where the Quinalt unit is in , Correct?? How big is the AHE area and what makes it so great? By the way the first year of the late muley special tags there were five in the gardner unit and that was our fourth choice and we drew 2 of the five. Should of bought a lotto!!