The original Boldt Decision gave the tribes 50% of the off reservation commercial catch. C&S and on reservation did not count in the sharing. Don't think you really want to go back to that. It was the Supremes, the second time around I believe, that lumped all catch together.

The Tribes have threatened to take to AK catch to court and have that count against the NI share. Don't know if they would also go after the WA rec catch in BC, too.

If the Tribes want to have the runs restrored to levels at treaty times I am all for that for the watersheds that still have lots of anadromous access. In the other areas (Columbia, for example) hatcheries will be needed.