Generally and especially when there are listed stocks involved, total exploition rates are significantly lower than those historic rates, even when the are mixed H&W. Your argument is somewhat of a false choice as nobody fishes to those rates anymore and the wild fish don't really care who kills them or how or where. If you want to say that selective fishing is a more efficient use (economic benefit wise or NI rec fishery season length wise) of each dead wild fish, regardless of ER limitation, ok. Let's not delude ourselves into thinking we don't kill wild fish though, please.