I have a 1173, and I like it just fine with the exception of the short back handle. The SK or Skamania series rods were designed to be Michigan style grip, which would be the equivalent of choking up on a bat, your hand above the reel, if that is your preference. You could extend the rear handle or put on a counter balance in back to overcome the tip heavy feel I get with a Shimano Spirex 2000 attached. I have fished some of the Allstar rods and they are excellent, although I didn't fish one with comparable specs. The 1173 has good sensitivity and plenty of back bone to turn a large fish if neccisary, due to the nature of the stiffness of the GL3 graphite. I know, I've had to do it. Yet it does have a light enough tip to "circle" or flip cast a small spoon or spinner in tight situations, where long rods could prove problematic. If cost is a consideration, I would go with the Rain Shadow, If not and you prefer a Blue Lable manufacturer, the Loomis is a good choice.