What I take from the discussion so far:

There are 2 issues that get mixed up like ingredients in soup.

1) Impact of selective fishery on commercials.
2) Impact of Non-Selective Treaty Fisheries on ESA, % hatchery catch, total return of hatchery and wild fish.

1) Impact of selective fishery on commercials:
If selective fishing for commercials on the LCR were implemented, with an estimated mortality from the commercials of 10%, same as the recreationals. This would lead to an additional almost 11,00 hatchery fish harvest by the commercials, to equal 16,000, same as the recreationals.

This would be about 10% harvest of all hatchery fish by recreationals, and about 10% harvest of all hatchery fish by commercials.

Which leaves 80% for the treaty tribes as opposed to 87% under the previous plan. Is this correct? If so, it IS NOT "insignificant." 8 % is significant in any scientific discussion. If I am wrong, then educate me, please. And Thank You.

Selective Fishing by commercials would be beneficial.

2) Impact of Non-Selective Treaty Fisheries on ESA, % hatchery catch, total return of hatchery and wild fish.

Treaty agreers should be selective.
I can't put it any more clear than that there are major effects on lots and lots of downstream issues, including recreational fishers, from the Non Selective fisheries of the Non Coordinated treaty folks. Bad things.

I recognize that there are many very caring and responsible First Nation People and I pray they are able to step up. We all live in this world. If it were up to me, I would abrogate every treaty out there and start over. Why? Because the treaties are broken. They don't work out for the greater good. Just my considered, and personal, opinion. But I live in this world.

In summary:

There are 2 issues:
1) Commercial Gill netting
2) Treaty obligations

I differ from a few folks here in that I think the problem is NOT in getting the commercials to fish selectively ( I support CCA) but the issue is that All Treaty Participants should start fishing selectively.

Recreationals do it, commercials should, and First Nations should as well.