While it may be true that BC and AK have taken way too many fish, which the State, tribes, and Feds seem unwilling to fix, the fact is that the treaty gives the Tribes and non-Indians what shows up in WA waters. That is what they have to share. That is the pie to divide.

Or, should the Columbia tribes, for example, say we used to take 3 million a year before the dams and settlement. Therefore we get the first 3 million that enter the river.