F5A, very good post. I feel about how you do. Another point was made in the 20 page thread. This divides the fisherman. It fragments an already insufficient voice. But, there's a possibility the Hogan ruling will unite us once again with a common adversary.

IMO, whatever actions taken by fisherman in the future, it needs to include a plan with more vision than the current attempts to help the fish. A plan that ask for concessions from all involved, or that affects fishermen, developers, tribes and others collectively, and supported by unbiased science, is far more likely to get support.

As has been said before, WSR is a tool, not a plan. It seems very little thought went into how this would affet the larger picture, and what the reaction would be.