Originally Posted By: Lead Bouncer
Originally Posted By: freespool
[


Shut down fishing and see what happens? Isn't that exactly what we did with wild steelhead?
So what do you think happened?
Nothing, that's what, in spite of over 25 years of no retention and no commerical harvest, no ESA listed steelhead stock has been delisted.
So why in the world would we try that failed recovery option again?


SG?
How much spawning goes on below the dams? How effective is it with mass fluctuations in water level? If the wild fish are not spawning down below on the lewis and cowlitz, then how are the hatchery fish jeopardizing anything? All we see right now is large blanket of hatchery reduction in rivers that, may yield no increases. I dont know what the spawning activity is in the NFL below the dams, but since the collectors are $50-100 million and they are working on the first one, its going to be a long time before that experiment is going to yield results, since there are three dams. I do not know what collection facilities are in use now.

[/quote]

All spawning is below the Merwin Dam in the NF of the Lewis... There is a broodstock program starting in action as we speak... We'll see what happens... Sure has helped the Kalama River....

Keith
_________________________
It's time to put the red rubber nose away, clown seasons over.